Choose the right fulfilment method for your Amazon business and understand the differences between FBA, FBM and dropshipping for optimal success.
Jens Vittrup
Choosing the right fulfilment method is one of the most important decisions you will make as an Amazon seller. The three main options – Fulfilment by Amazon (FBA), Fulfilment by Merchant (FBM) and dropshipping – each come with their own advantages and challenges. Your choice impacts everything from your profit margins to day-to-day operations.
In this guide, we will review each model, compare Amazon FBA vs FBM, explore how Amazon FBA measures up against dropshipping, and help you determine which approach best fits your business goals. Let’s dive in and find out which fulfilment method is most suited to your Amazon sales journey.
FBA (Fulfilment by Amazon) is a service where you send your inventory directly to Amazon’s fulfilment centres. Once your products arrive, Amazon takes over the entire fulfilment process. They store your goods, pick and pack orders as they come in, ship products to customers and handle customer service and returns.
When a customer orders your product, you don’t need to do a thing – Amazon takes care of everything. This automation is why many sellers are attracted to the FBA model when starting their Amazon sales journey.
The FBA process works as follows:
A major advantage of Amazon FBA is Prime eligibility. Your products automatically qualify for Prime shipping, giving you access to Amazon’s most loyal customer base. These customers often filter search results to show only Prime-eligible items, giving FBA sellers a significant competitive edge.
FBM (Fulfilment by Merchant) means you handle the entire fulfilment process yourself. When you sell using the FBM model, you are responsible for storing inventory, processing orders, packing items, shipping them to customers, and handling customer service and returns.
The FBM process looks like this:
With FBM, you retain complete control over the fulfilment process. This hands-on involvement enables you to ensure quality control, personalise packaging and build direct relationships with your customers. It requires more hands-on management but eliminates the fees associated with Amazon’s fulfilment services.
Although FBM products are not automatically Prime-eligible, high-performing FBM sellers can qualify for Seller Fulfilled Prime. This programme allows you to display the Prime badge on your listings while handling fulfilment yourself, provided you meet Amazon’s strict delivery time requirements.
Dropshipping is fundamentally different from both FBA and FBM. With this model, you never physically handle the products you sell. Instead, when a customer purchases an item from your Amazon listing, you buy that product from a third-party supplier, who ships it directly to your customer.
The dropshipping process works as follows:
The main appeal of dropshipping is the minimal upfront investment. You do not need to purchase inventory in advance or worry about warehousing. This makes it an attractive option for new sellers with limited capital.
However, dropshipping on Amazon comes with strict rules. Amazon’s policy states that you must be the seller of record for all products and identify yourself as the seller on all packing slips and external packaging. You are also responsible for processing returns, even though you never physically handle the products.
When comparing Amazon FBA vs FBM, several factors come into play that can significantly impact your business operations and profitability. Understanding these differences is crucial for making an informed decision about which fulfilment method suits your business model.
With FBM, you retain full control over your inventory and the entire fulfilment process. This hands-on approach allows you to personally inspect products before shipping, customise packaging, and include promotional materials. You also have insight into every stage of the process from storage to delivery.
FBA transfers control to Amazon, which handles storage, packing and shipping according to their standardised processes. While this reduces your workload, you lose direct oversight of how your products are handled. Amazon’s tracking systems provide visibility, but you cannot directly monitor the physical handling of your goods.
The cost difference between FBA and FBM is significant and complex. With FBA, you pay several fees:
With FBM, you avoid Amazon’s fulfilment fees but take on direct costs:
For small, lightweight items or fast-moving inventory, FBA is often more cost-effective. For large, bulky items or slow-moving stock that attracts long-term storage fees, FBM often delivers better margins.
FBA significantly reduces your daily operational workload. Once inventory has been sent to Amazon, your time spent on fulfilment is minimal. This frees you up to focus on product sourcing, marketing and growing your business.
FBM requires a considerable time investment in order processing, packing, shipping and customer service. As your business grows, these responsibilities can increase and may require warehouse staff and sophisticated inventory management systems.
FBA leverages Amazon’s world-class fulfilment infrastructure and offers fast, reliable shipping, including next-day and same-day options in many areas. Amazon’s customer service handles buyer enquiries and returns requests, providing a consistent experience that customers trust.
With FBM, the customer experience depends entirely on your abilities. You must meet Amazon’s performance metrics, including requirements for on-time delivery and response times. While this allows for personalised service, it also places the burden of customer satisfaction squarely on your shoulders.
When evaluating Amazon FBA vs dropshipping, you will find fundamental differences in business models that affect start-up costs, control and scalability. Let’s break down these key differences to help determine which approach might work better for your business goals.
The most significant difference between FBA and dropshipping is inventory investment. With FBA, you must purchase inventory in advance, representing a substantial initial capital outlay. You will need to forecast demand, manage stock levels and tie up cash in physical products before making any sales.
Dropshipping eliminates this upfront inventory investment entirely. You only purchase products after receiving customer orders, which creates a cash flow advantage. This low-risk entry point makes dropshipping attractive to new sellers with limited capital or those testing new product categories.
FBA typically offers better profit margins when you consider all costs. By purchasing inventory in bulk directly from manufacturers, you secure wholesale prices that allow for healthy margins, even after Amazon’s fulfilment fees are taken into account.
Dropshipping margins are generally slimmer. Since you are buying products one at a time at near-retail prices after receiving orders, your cost per unit is higher. You will also be competing with other dropshippers selling identical products, which often leads to price competition that further squeezes margins.
With FBA, you inspect inventory before sending it to Amazon’s warehouses, allowing you to verify product quality and condition. This quality control step helps maintain positive customer reviews and reduce return rates. Amazon’s fulfilment network also provides reliable, consistent shipping times that customers can depend on.
Dropshipping introduces uncertainty in both product quality and delivery. As you never physically handle the products, you cannot verify their condition before they reach customers. You are also reliant on your suppliers’ shipping capabilities, which can vary in reliability and speed. These factors can lead to customer disappointment and negative reviews that damage your seller reputation.
FBA streamlines daily operations once your inventory is in Amazon’s fulfilment centres. Amazon manages storage, picking, packing, shipping and basic customer service, allowing you to focus on product selection, sourcing and optimising your listings.
Dropshipping involves more ongoing operational tasks. You must process each order individually, communicate with suppliers, track shipments and manage customer expectations around delivery times. If a supplier runs out of stock after you have accepted an order, you need to quickly handle customer communication and find alternative sourcing solutions.
When comparing FBM vs FBA on Amazon, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. The right choice depends on your specific business circumstances, product characteristics and long-term objectives. Let’s examine when each model makes the most sense.
FBA tends to be the better option in these scenarios:
FBA is particularly well suited to sellers who value time freedom and scalability. The ability to handle sudden sales surges without operational strain makes it ideal for growing businesses. The Prime badge also typically increases conversion rates and can enhance your products’ advertising performance.
FBM often works better in these situations:
Businesses with existing warehousing and shipping capabilities often find FBM more profitable. It is also advantageous for unique products that benefit from customised handling or specialised quality control that Amazon’s standardised processes cannot deliver.
Many successful Amazon sellers use a hybrid approach, strategically leveraging both fulfilment methods. This flexibility allows you to optimise operations based on product characteristics, seasonal factors and shifting market conditions.
With a hybrid strategy, you can:
This balanced approach allows you to maximise the benefits of both systems while minimising their drawbacks. Many experienced sellers find that this flexibility gives them a competitive edge in adapting to Amazon’s ever-changing market dynamics.
When examining what is the difference between Amazon FBA and dropshipping, we need to consider fundamental aspects of these business models that affect everything from start-up costs to daily operations. These differences will help clarify which model suits your resources and business vision.
FBA operates on a traditional retail model where you purchase inventory upfront and then sell it at a profit. This requires significant initial investment but generally delivers higher profit per unit. Your cash flow cycle involves periods where capital is tied up in inventory until sales convert it back into liquid assets.
Dropshipping follows a just-in-time model where customer payment is received before you purchase inventory. This creates positive cash flow from day one, as you use the customer’s payment to fulfil their order. While this reduces financial risk, it typically results in lower profit margins because you are buying products individually rather than in bulk.
FBA offers stronger brand building opportunities. You can create customised packaging, include inserts and control the unboxing experience (before sending to Amazon). You also choose exactly which products represent your brand, and can ensure consistent quality through direct supplier relationships and quality control processes.
Dropshipping offers limited branding opportunities. Products are shipped directly from suppliers, often in generic packaging or even with the supplier’s branding. You have minimal control over the physical presentation of products, making it harder to create memorable customer experiences that build brand loyalty.
Scaling an FBA business typically requires proportional increases in capital investment for additional inventory. However, the fulfilment infrastructure automatically scales through Amazon’s network. Your focus remains on inventory management, product selection and marketing strategy rather than operational logistics.
Dropshipping scales with less capital required, but introduces different challenges. As order volume increases, so too does the complexity of managing multiple suppliers, tracking numerous shipments and handling customer service enquiries about delivery times. Your operational workload grows linearly with sales volume.
FBA carries inventory risk – the possibility that products do not sell as quickly as expected or may become obsolete, damaged, or lost while in storage. This risk increases with seasonal items, trendy products or categories with rapid innovation cycles. You also face potential changes in Amazon’s policies that could impact storage fees or product eligibility.
Dropshipping minimises inventory risk but introduces supplier dependency risk. If suppliers change prices, run out of stock, discontinue products or deliver poor quality items, your business is directly affected. You also face increased competition risk, as the barrier to entry is low and product differentiation is minimal.
For sellers exploring Amazon’s marketplace, understanding what is Amazon FBA and FBM is essential. These two fulfilment methods represent fundamentally different approaches to Amazon selling, each with distinct operational implications.
Amazon FBA (Fulfilment by Amazon) is a service where Amazon handles storage, packaging, shipping, customer service and returns on your behalf. You send your inventory to Amazon’s fulfilment centres, and they take care of the rest. When customers order your products, Amazon staff pick, pack and ship the items directly to the buyer.
Amazon FBM (Fulfilment by Merchant) means you handle all aspects of the fulfilment process yourself. You list products on Amazon’s marketplace, but you store your own inventory, process orders manually, pack and ship goods yourself, and deal with all customer service queries and returns directly.
The main difference lies in who manages the fulfilment process – with FBA, Amazon does the heavy lifting; with FBM, you retain full control but also carry full responsibility. This fundamental distinction cascades into various operational, financial and strategic considerations for your business.
When considering which is better – Amazon FBA or dropshipping, the answer depends on your resources, business objectives and risk tolerance. Each model offers different advantages that may suit your specific situation better.
FBA requires significant start-up capital to purchase inventory in bulk, prepare it for Amazon’s warehouses and ship it to fulfilment centres. This initial investment can range from several thousand to tens of thousands of pounds depending on your product category and inventory depth.
Dropshipping allows you to start with minimal capital – essentially just the cost of setting up your Amazon seller account and any product research tools you may use. As you only purchase products after receiving customer orders, you can launch with a fraction of the investment needed for FBA.
FBA offers superior work-life balance once your system is established. After sending inventory to Amazon, your daily operational requirements are minimal. You will primarily focus on monitoring performance, managing stock levels and making strategic decisions rather than handling day-to-day fulfilment tasks.
Dropshipping can be more demanding on your time. Each order requires individual processing, communication with suppliers and tracking to ensure correct delivery. Customer service queries about shipping status, delays or quality issues require constant attention and problem solving.
FBA businesses tend to build more sustainable competitive advantages over time. By controlling your supply chain, building supplier relationships and potentially developing unique products, you create barriers to entry that protect your market position. Your brand value accumulates with every satisfied customer.
Dropshipping businesses face ongoing sustainability challenges. Low barriers to entry mean competitors can easily copy your product selection. Without control over the fulfilment experience, it becomes harder to build lasting brand value. Supplier relationships remain shallow, as you typically represent a small part of their business.
Many sellers who start with dropshipping eventually transition to FBA as they gain market knowledge and accumulate capital. The learning experience from dropshipping provides valuable insights about product selection and customer preferences that can later inform a more capital-intensive FBA strategy.
For those wishing to develop specialised expertise in this area, Amazon courses often cover the transition strategy from dropshipping to FBA as businesses evolve.
After exploring the different fulfilment methods available to Amazon sellers, it is time to consolidate this information and make a practical decision for your business. This closing section provides a framework for evaluating which model – or combination of models – will best serve your specific circumstances.
Your available capital significantly influences which model makes sense as your starting point:
Remember, undercapitalisation is a common reason for e-commerce failure. Whatever model you choose, ensure you have sufficient resources not just to launch, but to maintain operations through the initial growth phase.
Your time constraints and lifestyle goals play a crucial role in determining the most suitable model:
If you are building your Amazon business alongside other commitments such as full-time employment, the automation advantages of FBA may outweigh the higher start-up costs.
Your product selection should influence your fulfilment strategy:
In many cases, the physical characteristics and margin structure of your products will naturally point towards one fulfilment method over others.
Remember, your initial choice is not permanent. Many successful Amazon businesses evolve their fulfilment strategy over time, starting with one model and transitioning to another as they grow and their circumstances change. The key is to make an informed decision based on your current resources and constraints while maintaining flexibility for future development.
By thoroughly evaluating these factors and aligning them with your business goals, you will be well positioned to choose the fulfilment method – or combination of methods – that provides the best foundation for your Amazon sales success.
For more detailed guidance on implementing your chosen strategy, you may wish to explore Amazon FBA services, which can help streamline your operations and maximise your potential on the marketplace. Alternatively, you can seek support from experienced Amazon consultants, who can guide you through the process and help you make the right decision for your business.
At WeMarket, we offer businesses a benchmark report that compares their marketing efforts with their key competitors. You decide which competitors we should compare against.
We specialise in selling physical goods online and growing webshops – and now you can benefit from this expertise, even if you’re not already a client.
It’s completely free.
